Saturday, March 28, 2009

The Future of Comics?

Hey gang.

Got involved in an interesting conversation at the comic shop yesterday. Marc Nathan, the man who runs the Baltimore Comic-Con came into the shop to talk to the owner Rusty (most of you know that, duh) and was discussing a meeting he attended in Memphis. The subject turned to the price point of comics, which I'm sure most of you have seen or heard about. For those who haven't, it seems that the price of comics has moved from 2.99 to 3.99. This is not done for every comic, just among the big 2 (Marvel and DC).

At the meeting, the Marvel president said the the price change was "something they were testing the waters on to see if there was a market for it" if memory serves. DC said the price change would affect those books that added more story, so you'll get more bang for the buck (in theory). In the course of this discussion, a motive for Marvel seemingly arbitrary price increase is to try and kill the market was posed. To drive the price so that people wouldn't want the books, I guess. There appears to be some facts behind this theory. Recently there was an announcement at a con about SPIDER-WOMAN preview or #1 being released only online for a period before heading to the comic shops. The only way to see this comic is to be a subscriber to Marvel's digital comics line, which costs an amount per month. You'll have to forgive me if I'm not completely and totally factual. I remember a time about a year or so ago that Marvel announced this and at the time, I was financially unavailable to do this. It sounded like a great idea at the time. You would eventually have access to the entire back catalogue of Marvel comics, stretching back now 70 years.

Now, I love a good conspiracy theory as much as the next guy, but the idea that Marvel would eventually go totally digital and no longer have current material at the brick and mortar stores sounds....suicidal to me. I am old enough to remember when Marvel tried to make a power play to have their own distribution (breaking away from behemoth Diamond) in the early '90s. It was a disaster and left customers and retailers confused and angry. They abandoned it in a short period of time and returned to Diamond's fold. This doesn't sound like that, but in a roundabout way, could be just as disastrous. Most of us comic fans read our books in other places, like the bedroom, in a comfortable chair in the living room, or even the bathroom. We don't sit for hours on end staring at a computer screen catching up on the events in Spider-Man or Batman's lives. We like being comfortable when we are transported to another world, not hogging the computer at home (work would be another matter). I think that Marvel underestimates comic fans (no big surprise here). There would be a large section of fans who would follow them into the internet. That's why they're called Marvel Zombies. However, I think a large section of fans would head somewhere else. They would give IDW or BOOM a try. They would pick up something from DC, Image or Dark Horse instead.

What I'm trying to say is that while there is a demand and marketplace for comics on the internet, to totally remove yourself from what made you who you are is to cut your off at the knees for no good reason. I say this while also being sad that a few months ago, Scott Kurtz announced that he was cancelling his brilliant PvP book at #50. But, in fairness to Scott, he did start out as a webcomic and is still continuing to do a 5 day a week strip. They just wont be collected in true comic form. Sad, yes, but I'm sure that there will be trades from time to time.

So, what is your opinion? Think Marvel's idea is brilliant or sucks on ice? Drop me a comment and if I should get enough of them (more than 1) I'll post with either a comment or a polite rebuttal. Thanks!

3 comments:

Shawn said...

I liked this post my friend.

Marvel won't go all digital tomorrow. (I think.) But there is definitely a market and they are going to try and tap it.

I love books from the Big Two, but as always when you become a fat cat you forget that there are other options for good comics. And sometimes, much better comics.

Now they may come at a better price if Marvel keeps upping theirs. At least on $3.99 books from Templesmith at IDW you can see the quality in the paper stock and cover before you ever touch the story. (With is usually pretty good if not great.)

SECRET INVASION wasn't horrible, but it wasn't worth $3.99 a damn issue.

Ron said...

According to Marc (and I don't think I can really speak for him) the theory is that within 2 years Marvel wants to go all digital.

Not sure if this is his or Marvel's or the overall feeling he got from the retailers.

And we all know how calm and reasonable they are.

Jim said...

Ron - I have rambled on this subject before, but I think what Marvel is doing is trying to create a new base of fans and hoping to drive some of the Zombies to the web. They are not abandoning the printed form, but realize they have a greater chance to access 6 Billion people via the web. The idea is that if they can charge $5 a month and generate 5 million readers, the actual books become an after thought.

I also do not think Marvel went to $4 to end the market, I think it is a move to maximize their profits. They see BOOM/IDW and all making $4 books that sell and figure why not. They tag their biggest selling series and mini-series as test balloons. Plus if you have a budget of $40 for the month, Marvel feels they will get a higher share of that budget.

The print medium is in a declining cycle and all publishers who are smart are looking for ways to survive into tomorrow.

If print comics disappear I'll read collections, but I have already been a slight convert to digital books as I have reviewed a fair amount of books via a PDF.

Wait till they make e-books that can display comics well, then even dinosaurs like me may be willing to switch.

From a pure financial profit model it is very attractive to think that you could eliminate the printing press, distributor and store. Hell you could charge $2 for a comic that way and still make more money for the same sales then via the current distribution model.

Bottom line is how do you grow your market and maximize your profits. In front of store owners they are going to say the right things, but ultimately the stores survival or not is not their concern.